
Well, I just unloaded a 'manuscript' on some sucker publisher, so now I've got a bit more time to blog.
Why not celebrate with a long-ish post that will surely attract a zillion comments? Without further ado --
I've often commented with bemusement on the German obsession with Scientology. Above, we see a demonstration against Scientology that I passed by last year; the protesters were holding signs asking motorists to honk if they were 'against' Scientology, and dozens did just that.
The protesters belong to a group called 'Anonymous', which declared 'war' (g) against Scientology last year. Hackers associated with the group have hacked into Scientology's computers, releasing its internal data (g). I must confess, it was a tad unsettling to see people going out into the streets to call upon their fellow citizens to openly express their dislike of some religious minority. (Yes, plenty of people will say they're not a religion, but to me, the answer to that question -- even if anyone could agree on what a satisfactory answer would look like -- isn't really important.) I'm not going to throw around any accusations here, but this is really the sort of thing that Germans might want to think twice about doing.
But it's not just individual crusaders. As I've detailed elsewhere on this blog, the German government spends millions of taxpayer dollars investigating and monitoring Scientology, which has led to mild diplomatic tension with the U.S. government, which considers official surveillance of and discrimination against Scientology members a form of discrimination.
But it's all for a good cause, right? Because Scientology preys on the weak and the ignorant? Well, not so much, according to an article called '
6 Bullshit Facts about Psychology that Everyone Believes':
Studies show cult members are just as intelligent, if not more so, than the general public. And around 95 percent of cult members are perfectly sane (when they join up, anyway), with no history at all of real psychological problems. They're not stupid, and they're not crazy.
Of course this only serves to make cults even scarier. How in the hell do these groups get people--who are every bit as sane and smart as your best friend--to join up?
OK, ask yourself this: Why do rebellious biker types all immediately go out and start dressing and talking exactly like other biker types?
As social animals we are hard-wired to want to belong to a group. It's a need as basic and real as hunger or sex. When we get cut off from our group--say we lose a job, or move to a new city, or break up with our girlfriend--we go a little crazy. Cults are very, very good at finding people in that exact moment of weakness, and saying exactly the right things....
If you can't remember ever doing something dumb and embarrassing because you were feeling lonely and rejected, well, either you're very young, or you were just too drunk at the time to retain the memory.
And once these people are in the cult they realize that, no, not all cult members wind up as part of some bizarre suicide ceremony. Most lead normal, successful lives.
Now, take it for what it's worth, since it's from a site called Cracked Magazine. But I don't find anything very implausible about this. People can combine strong beliefs in very odd things with leading outwardly normal, law-abiding lives.
I'm still trying to understand why German authorities and ordinary citizens (like all the ones that honked in response to the protesters) are so terrified of Scientology. I suppose it's probably because Scientology is weird, it's American, and it's commercial. But that still doesn't add up to a justification for widespread government surveillance and hacker campaigns and the like. I find Scientology's beliefs just as odd as the next person, but I see them as essentially harmless, because:
(1) My general orientation is 'the more odd beliefs, the better' This may be be a personality quirk, or it may be my Anglo-Saxonness live-and-let-live-iness. Whenever I see demonstrations against Scientology, I'm always reminded of Ralf Dahrendorf's quip that if the Beatles had been a German band, a campaign called 'Aktion Saubere Buehne' would have immediately emerged to stop them.
(2) I've never heard any accusations against Scientology that weren't comparable to what plenty of other institutions do -- in particular, certain religious institutions subsidized by German church taxes. For instance, I don't recall anyone accusing Scientology of covering up a massive sex abuse scandal for decades.
(3) even if one were able to stamp out Scientology (as disturbing a goal as that is), is anyone naive enough to think that another comparable organization wouldn't immediately replace it? People don't join Scientology because they're in love with Xenu, they join because it provides them with a sense of purpose and meaning in life, and a community to rely on. These are universal human desires which will find some outlet somewhere, and often find outlets much, much uglier and more dangerous than Scientology.
Recent Comments