Zedler's Recipe for Spiced Beer Against Melancholy
Country X Doesn't Care What You Think About its Laws

Our Mothers, Our Fathers as an Anti-War Film

I watched Unsere Mütter, Unsere Väter ('Our Mothers, Our Fathers'), the three-part German miniseries that has recently been released to decidedly mixed reviews in the USA under the title 'Generation War'. In the New York Times, A.O. Scott calls it

an attempt to normalize German history. Its lesson is that ordinary Germans — “Our Mothers, Our Fathers,” in the original title — were not so different from anyone else, and deserve the empathy and understanding of their grandchildren.'

...There is good and bad on all sides, a dash of mercy mixed into the endless violence. But the suggestion that the Nazis were not the only bad guys in Eastern Europe in the early 1940s is undermined by the film’s disinclination to show the very worst of what the Nazis did. We see massacres of Jews by local militias in Ukraine under the supervision of the SS, but “Generation War,” for all its geographical range and military detail, steers clear of the death camps.

This omission has the effect of at least partly restoring the innocence of the characters and of perpetuating the notion that ordinary Germans were duped by the Nazis and ignorant of the extent of their crimes — that they were as much Hitler’s victims as his accomplices and did not know what he was doing. They also suffered, after all, but there is something troubling about how the filmmakers apportion this suffering.

Virtually all the reviews name-check the various controversies the film provoked -- Poles were especially frustrated by the depiction of Polish anti-Semitism among partisans.

I rather liked the movie. One thing that American reviewers may not appreciate is its simple technical proficiency. Americans are spoiled -- standards of dialogue, narrative pacing and production design are now so uniformly high in American television series that Americans take it for granted that backgrounds and sets will appear extremely plausible and detailed down to the last cigarette butt or car model, and that dialogue will sound as if it were actually being produced by people in the periods and professions the actors portray. This doesn't mean that show is worth watching or the plot is plausible, but the technical stuff will seem right.

In German shows, alas, this basic level of proficiency can't be taken for granted. Generation War looks authentic, although I'm sure there are minor flaws here and there. The combat scenes are chaotic and gritty, basically copies of Steven Spielberg. Which is fine by me -- nobody does combat scenes in middlebrow war movies better than Spielberg, and there's not much room for individual experimentation, so why not copy the master? The director, Philipp Kadelbach, has worked hard at creating a bloody, gritty, nasty, violent combat background, and deserves kudos for pulling that off.

It's also refreshing to see a German movie that other nations are interested in seeing. German cinema is in at least the third decade of doldrums, producing far too many portentous didactic pieces about parochial social issues or navel-gazing rides on the hobbyhorses of the urban bourgeoisie. Germans are well aware of this problem, which is the subject anguished hand-wringing every year as the German Film Prize goes to yet another group of movies that few have seen and which sink rapidly into oblivion.

One of the culprits is the script review process, necessary to get the public funds with which these movies are made. Any juice these movies might have had is patiently extracted during this process, in which squeamish, picky film bureaucrats carefully remove most traces of originality, political incorrectness, or excessive action. I myself have seen a film script with the review marks of numerous of these prigs, whose favorite means of removing interesting scenes from movies is the phrase 'zu Hollywood' (too Hollywood). Generation War is hardly profound auteur cinema, but it's a gripping, well-made middlebrow drama with well-defined characters (the cast, as is usually the case in German movies, is outstanding) and which doesn't shy away from controversy.

The critics who carp that the movie doesn't do precely-calibrated justice to all who suffered under German rule (no death camps? Polish anti-Semites?) are missing the point. The typical German film would have tried to placate every constituency, and would for just that reason have been a pedagogic exercise. The movie focusses on the five main characters, showing 'their' wars. We see German soldiers committing plenty of atrocities, and witness ordinary Germans gleefully parroting militaristic and anti-Semitic propaganda, denouncing one another, and ruthlessly executing women and children. Not all of the five main characters survive, and the ones who do are all morally compromised. The fact that they also display some sympathetic qualities such as loyalty to friends hardly counts as whitewashing.

American critics seem blind to the fact that Generation War is an anti-war film. Americans and Britons approach a German movie about World War II with an iron framework of anticipations and preconceptions that focus narrowly on one question: Are the Germans somehow trying to whitewash their unspeakable past? Once you put aside this tired framing, you see that Generation War is about the human stupidity, groupthink, and cowardice that lead to war. The non-Jewish German characters start out swallowing Hitler's propaganda about a quick war and the international Judeo-Bolshevik conspiracy (while excepting their Jewish friend Viktor Goldstein under the motto of Karl Lueger, former mayor of Vienna: 'Wer ein Jud' ist, bestimme ich' (g) -- 'I decide who's a Jew'). The rest of the movie grinds each of the four non-Jewish characters through a relentless nightmare of betrayal, hypocrisy, moral corruption, and violence that kills a few of them and leaves the rest permanently scarred and profoundly cynical. The viewer is meant to experience this as just retribution for their gullibility and gradually-expanding complicity in evil.

Generation War is a German movie that shows the horror and futility of any war anywhere. It's a straightforward, not-particularly-subtle morality tale about the dangers of nationalism and militarism. American critics might have given that aspect of the movie some thought, considering that just 11 years ago, Americans were -- with truly embarrassing ease -- suckered into supporting a pointless, brutal occupation that has now left over a million injured, 270,000 of whom have brain injuries (counting Afghanistan), not to mention the countless millions of Iraqis and Afghans killed and injured. Whether the echo was intentional or not, it's telling that one of the German characters, fighting partisans and the Red Army on the front lines in Russia, muses bitterly that just three years ago, the German army was 'greeted as liberators' from Bolshevism.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Ralph

I watched the first hour of the series; though I have seen far worse, I didn't find it that appealing: character stereotypes, plodding plot, sentimental clichés. Nevertheless, based on the little I did see, I can't entirely share Scott's opinion, either.

The continuing German project of Vergangenheitsbewältigung--coming to terms with the Nazi past and its crimes--has been successful in many respects, in some others not so much. This television series, though, is, at least partly, a success.

There's no such thing as a specifically German fascist gene. Other societies have also been subject to mob psychology and political intimidation. Many Germans did succumb, including leading intellectuals, to the Nazi lure and they should be held responsible for their actions; but most Germans were, in fact, "ordinary people" in extraordinary circumstances.

This said not to excuse or relativize their complicity, passive or active, but their blanket condemnation can't be the right way to close the wound.

Junger Gott

I read through all the reviews on Rotten Tomatoes.
The general consensus seems to be that the movie had some decent battle scenes but storywise depended too much on unlikely encounters and cliches. Having watched the movie, I think I can agree with that.

What I found mystifying though was that many reviews seemed to positively dispute the fact that there actually was a sizable Jewish people in Berlin in 1941. Haven't those guys never heard of the Rosenstrasse protests in 1943, so even two years later? I'm not saying you need to know to call yourself educated. But I would have expected some research into before the reviewers made sweeping statements to that effect.

Peter

Thanks. Very lucid review. I had read a review, in the New Republic if my memory serves me right, and was annoyed about the US view on that show. Also, I really liked the connect you made to German film boards and how in that way the show is actually innovative and untypically German.

S.

Had to switch off UMUV halfway through part two, there was no dramatic tension and I could never get into the story. It was a hybrid that wanted to meld a history lesson with epic drama and ended up doing neither well.

How about a moratorium on new WW II / Holocaust / Hitler / Nazi movies and documentaries... for the next 30 years or so. Within the past 60+ years, so many shows have been made already, there is nothing left to say.

Instead -- and this is meant seriously, not sarcastically -- one of the 50+ channels on German cable could re-run the already existing films 24/7. Have it be like water that comes out of the tap when you want to turn it on. And keep the public libraries stocked with the literature. But stop making new films.

The comments to this entry are closed.